(Must be first, second or third team to be recognized on this page)
| Baseball | |||
| Lawson Andrews, 1963 Steve Goodman, 1973 Randy Thomas, 1976 Jim White, 1976 Buddy Bailey, 1977 Jack Hobbs, 1978 | Dwayne Kitts, 1978 Scott McGahan, 1978 Dwayne Kitts, 1979 Jimmy Stinnett, 1980 Chip Childress, 1981 Mark Smith, 1981 | Chip Childress, 1982 Wayne Harrison, 1982 Shawn Delaney, 1983 Wayne Harrison, 1983 Tom Harris, 1990 | Anthony Palmisano, 2004 Steven Scott, 2004 Shawn Abell, 2004 Lucas Jones, 2005 |
| Men's Basketball | ||
| Wayne Profitt, 1966 | Wayne Profitt, 1967 | E.D. Schechterly, 1980 |
| Women's Basketball | ||
| Betty Jackson, 1983 | ||
| Men's Cross Country | ||
| Gregg Cavaliere, 1990 | Gregg Cavaliere, 1991 | John Cardwell, 1993 |
| Field Hockey | ||
| Molly Brogan, 1981 Phebe Phelps, 1981 Phebe Phelps, 1983 Terry Apperson, 1984 Kappie Fraher, 1985 | Lisa Coroneos, 1989 Sally Hoyer, 1991 Kara Summers, 1992 Kara Summers, 1993 Kara Summers, 1994 | Sarah Gioffre, 1996 Linda Jack, 2001 Linda Jack, 2002 Andrea Fleming, 2004 |
| Golf | ||
| Doug Howard, 1976 Mike Buhler, 1977 Rick Thayer, 1979 | Sam Martin, 1980 David Graham, 1983 Tom Pellatti, 1984 | David Graham, 1985 Tom Pellatti, 1985 |
| Men's Lacrosse |
| Paul Venturella, 2003 Brandon Childs, 2003 Ryan Johnson, 2003 Billy McCulloch, 2005 Chad Clark, 2006 Ryan Cranston, 2007 Brandon Fell, 2007 |
| Women's Lacrosse | ||
| Terry Apperson, 1983 Kerry Berman, 1983 Nancy Maroney, 1983 Terry Apperson, 1984 Nancy Maroney, 1984 Terry Apperson, 1985 | Kappie Fraher, 1985 Annie Overton, 1985 Kappie Fraher, 1986 Annie Overton, 1986 Allison Daly, 1988 Alicia Galione, 1988 | Donna Hansen, 1990 Kate Bowie, 1990 Donna Hansen, 1991 Carolyn Roth, 1997 |
| Men's Soccer | ||
| Helmut Werner, 1960 Glen Taylor, 1963 Rusty Taylor, 1966 Rusty Taylor, 1967 | Eric Wagner, 1969 Tom Emmons, 1978 Tom Emmons, 1979 John Canterbury, 1982 | John Toutkaldjian, 1982 John Amorim, 1983 Tracy Roark, 1984 |
| Women's Soccer | ||
| Kristen Kowit, 1999 Kristen Kowit, 2000 | Carrie Webster, 2001 Erin Johnson, 2004 | Kim Vaughan, 2004 |
| Softball |
| Caroline Cubbage, 2004 Caroline Cubbage, 2006 Brittany Edelen, 2006 Caroline Cubbage, 2007 |
| Men's Swimming | ||
| Henry Mierzwa, 1971 | ||
| Men's Tennis | ||
| Conrad Frey, 1981 Conrad Frey, 1982 | Conrad Frey, 1983 | Jim Sargeant, 1984 |
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | ||
| James Walker, 1990 James Walker, 1991 Gregg Cavaliere, 1993 Seth McGuffin, 1994 Seth McGuffin, 1995 Dave Lichtenstein, 1998 Dave Lichtenstein, 1998 James Goss, 1999 Johnny Harris, 1999 | Jason Smith, 1999 Kevin Smith, 1999 Safwan Williams, 1999 James Goss, 2000 Jason Smith, 2000 Kevin Smith, 2000 Mark Sprague, 2000 Safwan Williams, 2000 Safwan Williams, 2000 | James Goss, 2001* James Goss, 2001 Kevin Smith, 2001* Kevin Smith, 2001 Johnny Harris, 2001 Safwan Williams, 2001 Josh Zobenica, 2003 Mike Lansdowne, 2005 Ryan Holmes, 2006 Ryan Holmes, 2007 * National Champion |
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | |||
| Joe Killeen, 1985 Major Tallent, 1986 * James Walker, 1989 James Walker, 1990 Tracy Lewis, 1992 Gregg Cavaliere, 1993 Gregg Cavaliere, 1993 Matt Richards, 1993 Seth McGuffin, 1994 Seth McGuffin, 1995 Seth McGuffin, 1995 Joe Bedard, 1996 | Joe Bedard, 1997 * Joe Bedard, 1998 * Joe Bedard, 1998 Dave Lichtenstein, 1998 James Goss, 1999 Johnny Harris, 1999 * Johnny Harris, 1999 Jason Smith, 1999 * Jason Smith, 1999 Kevin Smith, 1999 * Kevin Smith, 1999 Safwan Williams, 1999 * | Safwan Williams, 1999 * James Goss, 2000 James Goss, 2000 James Goss, 2000 Johnny Harris, 2000 Kevin Smith, 2000 Safwan Williams, 2000 * Safwan Williams, 2000 James Goss, 2001 James Goss, 2001 Johnny Harris, 2002 Josh Zobenica, 2003 * National Champion | Doug Thomasey, 2004 |
| Women's Indoor Track & Field | ||
| Amy Edwards, 1996 | Vicki Osinga, 2000 | Ashley Palmer, 2004 |
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | ||
| Missy Beaver, 1998 | Megan Wiseman, 2002 | Ashley Palmer, 2004 |
| Vick Osinga, 1999 | Megan Wiseman, 2003 | Ashley Palmer, 2005 |
